Authorized Flender Gearbox Rebuild Shop

Pump Repair vs. Replacement: How to Make the Right Decision For Your Business

The need for pumps in industrial and commercial applications cannot be overstated. They are necessary for keeping things running as they should, so any shutdown or issues related to these pumps can cause major disruptions. The pump failures can be caused by a variety of factors, including mechanical wear, corrosion, and contamination. Depending on the severity of the damage, you may be left with two choices: pump repair or replacement. So, how do you know which option is right for you? Read the post to learn about the factors you should consider when making the decision to opt between pump replacement or pump repair services.

Pump Repair Vs. Replacement

Key Criteria to Consider When Opting for Pump Replacement or Pump Repair Services

Several factors must be taken into account when deciding whether to repair or replace a pump. Finding the root cause of the issue is the first step. Following the discovery of the root cause, a choice can be made based on the following factors.

  • Age of the Pump: The age of a pump is an important factor to consider when deciding between repair or replacement. Depending on the application, expected lifespan and other elements, the age of a pump may heavily influence this choice. Pumps typically endure for several years of use in challenging environments before demanding a change. However, this does not mean that you should never repair your pump. If your pump is starting to show signs of wear and tear, it may be time for a repair. But if your pump is very old, it may be a more cost-effective and wise decision to replace it.
  • Extent of Damage: Before deciding whether to repair or replace the pump, it is essential to perform an inspection, identify the damage’s root cause, and evaluate its severity. A visual examination of the pump and its surroundings can help you gain useful information. For instance, if there is fire damage, it is likely that the pump cannot be fixed and must be replaced. Your pump may sustain anything from a minor crack or leak to total ruin. The choice of whether to repair or replace the pump can be made when the cause and extent of the damage have been identified.
  • Timing for Repair and Replacement: When determining whether to repair or replace a pump, it is important to consider the timeline of each option. A repair job can usually be completed within a few days while an order for a new pump can take up to eight weeks before being delivered. Carefully weighing the benefits and potential costs of either approach is key – if you need the part right away and are willing to pay more for quickly-completed repairs, opting for pump repair services would be the ideal choice. However, if your business will tolerate waiting for a new pump and it makes financial sense, making a replacement is another viable option.
  • Cost of Repair VS Replacement: Ultimately, the cost is a major factor in deciding whether to repair or replace your mechanical and electrical pumps. Single stage pumps that are used for light industrial or HVAC applications have a relatively low unit price and often it makes economic to opt for replacement over repair. However, large pumps require more wear-resistant components, resulting in a higher cost. Consequently, repairs may be more cost-effective in this situation.

Making a decision to repair or replace a pump is not always an easy one. There are many factors to consider, as mentioned above such as the age of the pump, the severity of the damage, and the cost of repairs. If you are having difficulty making the decision, it is best to consult with a professional EASA approved and UL listed repair center like Motor and Gear Engineering as they carefully weigh all of the options and make the best decision for your company.

If you work with EBARA Pump and KSB pumps, you can easily contact them. The company is today regarded one of the leading EBARA and KSB pump repair services in the US. All repairs and overhauls of these pumps are handled by OEM trained and experienced technicians in the company. You can get in touch with the experts at the company today to discuss your requirements.